Table 4 Evaluation of REE with different predictive equations in overall children and adolescents with different BMIs based on differences predicted-measured, percentage of accuracy, bias, and RMSE according to genders (M/F)
Normal Weight (n = 105) | Overweight (n = 52) | Obese (n = 118) | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
REE predictive equations | Difference predicted-measured (kcal/d) | Accurate-prediction (%) | Bias (%) | RMSE (kcal/d) | Difference predicted-measured (kcal/d) | Accurate-prediction (%) | Bias (%) | RMSE (kcal/d) | Difference predicted-measured (kcal/d) | Accurate-prediction (%) | Bias (%) | RMSE (kcal/d) |
Tverskaya | 21/-10 | 61.1/62.7 | 5.0/1.1 | 202.5/152.4 | 120/13 | 48.1/60.0 | 9.2/2.9 | 231.8/184.7 | 209/147 | 38.8/41.2 | 21.0/12.9 | 412.7/307.2 |
Derumeaux-Burel | 108/98 | 55.6/54.9 | 9.7/9.7 | 210.7/179.9 | 212/124 | 25.9/56.0 | 14.2/10.6 | 295.9/224.4 | 261/255 | 29.9/58.8 | 24.4/20.4 | 446.3/376.7 |
Müller | -181/74 | 35.2/58.8 | -7.2/7.9 | 316.9/166.8 | -172/42 | 51.9/60.0 | -7.4/5.3 | 296.8/191.0 | -56/-3 | 29.9/45.1 | 4.2/2.6 | 397.3/265.7 |
Müller FFM | -102/92 | 51.9/54.9 | -2.9/9.0 | 246.7/176.6 | -40/79 | 63.0/56.0 | -0.4/7.6 | 200.2/217.7 | 56/71 | 40.3/45.1 | 10.8/7.6 | 367.7/264.7 |
Schmelze | 40/-95 | 55.6/62.7 | 6.0/-5.6 | 196.2/173.7 | 29/-123 | 66.7/48.3 | 3.6/-6.3 | 187.0/214.1 | 33/-8 | 38.8/43.1 | 8.5/2.1 | 341.5/262.7 |
Molnar | -259/-40 | 29.6/37.3 | -12.1/-2.2 | 332.2/214.8 | -172/11 | 51.9/44.0 | -7.1/3.5 | 271.0/215.7 | 61/13 | 37.3/41.2 | 11.5/3.5 | 356.4/274.6 |
H | -150/-57 | 42.6/74.5 | -8.3/-2.7 | 262.0/162.1 | -66/-69 | 44.4/48.0 | -3.8/-2.6 | 224.4/204.2 | 29/-7 | 41.8/41.2 | 6.8/2.5 | 358.5/267.0 |
IOM | -22/-51 | 63.0/64.7 | 1.7/-2.1 | 203.3/161.0 | 125/-23 | 40.7/48.0 | 9.4/0.1 | 238.6/246.7 | 293/-14 | 25.4/37.3 | 26.9/1.9 | 528.4/284.6 |
Schofield | -62/-46 | 53.7/64.7 | -0.4/-2.0 | 230.3/157.6 | 45/-57 | 59.3/52.0 | 4.6/-1.8 | 194.0/200.1 | 215/-6 | 41.8/39.2 | 20.9/2.6 | 397.3/269.8 |
WHO/FAO/UNU | -82/-20 | 53.7/58.8 | 1.7/0.3 | 240.4/157.1 | 43/5 | 59.3/56.0 | 4.5/-1.8 | 195.9/193.9 | 252/116 | 38.8/39.2 | 23.3/11.1 | 416.0/304.1 |
Kim | -42/-80 | 24.1/64.7 | -0.6/-4.2 | 408.0/166.4 | -225/-105 | 33.3/44.0 | -12.9/-5.0 | 345.9/228.0 | -147/-52 | 25.4/31.4 | -3.2/-1.0 | 404.7/269.9 |
Lazzer | -72/-85 | 42.6/54.9 | 0.9/-5.0 | 284.9/176.8 | 1/-52 | 48.1/52.0 | 3.3/-1.6 | 231.8/191.1 | 188/64 | 41.8/49.0 | 19.9/7.1 | 400.1/278.0 |
Lazzer FFM | -65/-72 | 40.7/51.0 | 2.2/-3.5 | 310.2/177.0 | 22/-44 | 44.4/48.0 | 4.9/-0.9 | 240.7/191.0 | 214/92 | 35.8/43.1 | 21.9/9.1 | 412.8/275.3 |
New Equation | -29/4 | 61.1/68.6 | 0.3/1.5 | 191.4/155.0 | 19/-13 | 77.8/40.0 | 2/0.8 | 193.4/210.7 | -3/26 | 38.8/39.2 | 6.5/4.5 | 349.3/269.6 |